Pros and Cons of Metal vs. Asphalt Roofing

Pros and Cons of Metal vs Asphalt Shingles Roofing

Roofing Services Now’s Metal Roof vs Asphalt Shingles Roofing Guide compares the pros, cons, differences, and costs of metal or panel roofing versus asphalt shingle roofs.

Count on Roofing Services Now to Advise Your Roof Materials Choice

Your roof serves as the protective barrier between your family and severe weather. Therefore, it’s essential to carefully pick roofing materials that match your unique circumstances, including the local climate, your home’s structure and any budget constraints.

The team at Roofing Services Now can guide you through the installation process, including material selection. However, if you’d rather pick on your own, follow this guide comparing the two most popular options: metal and asphalt.

Asphalt Roofing

Asphalt shingles are typically what first comes to mind when people imagine a roof. In these structures, stone-like slabs are layered over each other, creating the traditional shingle pattern.


More affordable: Shingles cost significantly less than alternatives. This is because asphalt is fairly cheap to produce, and shingle installation requires less skill than more specialized processes.

Enhanced warranties: Asphalt shingles typically come with a basic limited lifetime warranty. Oftentimes, these warranties extend for 30 or even 50 years, which is far longer than most options.

Versatile style: Given their traditional look, shingles are visually timeless. Plus, there are many types of asphalt styles, including luxury, three-tab or laminated shingles, meaning at least one look will probably suit your home.

Straightforward replacements: If you schedule regular maintenance services, shingles should survive for decades. However, extreme weather conditions and other unforeseen occurrences may damage your home. When this happens, asphalt makes roof repair extremely simple, as individual shingles can be quickly replaced.


Sensitive installation schedule: Unlike other materials, asphalt roofing shouldn’t be installed in the middle of winter. This is because extreme cold can create serious damage to the asphalt before the shingles are even secured.

Prone to mildew: When neglected, moisture will build and mildew might begin festering between shingle layers. For this reason, asphalt roofs demand more frequent cleaning.

Vulnerable to cracking and high winds: Both intense warmth and cold can cause shingles to fracture, meaning these roofs simply don’t last as long as more durable options. Depending on your situation, however, asphalt’s affordability may counteract this con.

Metal Roofing

These roofs, which are slightly less common than asphalt constructions, consist of interlocking metal panels. Alloys of copper, zinc or steel often appear in these panels, making them more resilient.


Longer lifespan: As previously hinted, metal roofs are more durable than asphalt, sometimes lasting up to 30 years longer. This is because alloys can more easily adapt to fluctuating temperatures, thus becoming less susceptible to fractures. This means you won’t have to pay for roof repairs nearly as often.

Lower maintenance: Unlike shingles, metal roofs don’t have the same gaps where mildew may form. Additionally, they can be power washed without the same fear of knocking away shingles.

Environmentally friendly: Finally, metal roofs are much more energy-efficient than alternative options. In the height of summer, metal can reflect heat instead of absorbing it, meaning you won’t have to dramatically boost your AC to stay cool. Asphalt shingles, on the other hand, tend to absorb heat.


Higher price tag: Given their resiliency, metal has a higher upfront cost than asphalt. In fact, these roofs can occasionally be up to ten times more expensive than shingles. There are usually more affordable metal options, though it may take some extra searching.

Unnecessary noise: Metal roofs don’t muffle sound as well as asphalt, particularly amid intense precipitation. During storms, some homeowners find the beating of rain irritating.

Easily dented: Though it doesn’t happen often, extreme hail or winds may dent metal panels. Since these roofs don’t consist of individual shingles, repairs tend to be more complicated.

Plan Your San Antonio Roof Installation

No matter which option you choose, as the preferred installation team for all of San Antonio, we have the experience and roofing materials necessary to construct the roof of your dreams. Contact us for an installation consultation today in less than 1 minute on our website.

Contact Us Here
or Call us at (210) 988-0188

We are local and family owned and operated in San Antonio
1777 NE Interstate 410 Loop Suite 600,
San Antonio TX 78217

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Serving San Antonio and its surrounding cities, we bring expert craftsmanship and unparalleled service to every project.


Terms & Conditions

© 2024 · Roofing Services Now, San Antonio